CALL 918-932-8314

If you’re in the market for a new roof, it’s important to consider all of your options. While there are many different types of roofs available, and each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, metal roofs and shingled roofs remain the most common roofing type chose by both commercial and residential property owners.

Both roofing types are durable and provide excellent coverage for a roof, but there are some distinct differences that make each roof better suited for certain applications. Here’s an overview of metal roof vs. shingle roof to help you make your decision.

What is the difference between metal roofs and shingled roofs?

While roofing materials have changed over the years, metal roofing and shingled roofing have remained two of the most popular roof types for both commercial and residential constructions.

Asphalt roofing is an affordable and durable material that can be used in any home. Asphalt roofing is available with different textures and colors, which allows it to suit any homeowner’s needs. It is also an easy roofing surface to repair, as roofers can simply apply a new roof shingle over the damaged one.

Metal roofing is becoming increasingly popular due to its low maintenance and long life span. A metal roof will not need to be replaced for at least 25 years, and it requires little maintenance work while protecting your home from damaging weather conditions.

Choosing the right roofing material can be a difficult decision. Some homeowners are concerned about their design preference, while others may need to consider either durability or climate in order to make an informed choice. One thing is certain though: it’s one of your most important investments for any property you own. Despite the differences between the two roofing materials, both are great options, and you will not regret your decision if you go with either one of them. But to help you make a well-informed decision, we have discussed the pros and cons of both metal and shingled roofs below.

Metal Roof Metal Roof

Metal roofing has a long history as being the most durable and reliable type of material for roofs. Metal’s durability can be traced back to ancient Rome when people in this era would use lead sheets on their rooftops because it could withstand any form of weather. Today, metal is still one of the best materials for keeping your house dry while you sleep soundly at night. Let’s have a look at the benefits and drawbacks of having a metal roof.

Benefits of Choosing Metal Roofs


One of the biggest benefits of using metal roofing is that it’s lightweight. Metal roof tiles can weigh 50% less than shingle roof tiles, and they are also much lighter to transport than fiber cement or wood roof trusses. This makes installation easier as you will not need any heavy equipment in order to roof your home, thereby cutting costs. As roofing companies will not need to hire cranes for installing roof tiles, there will be fewer accidents that could happen while roofing your house.

Easy to maintain

Metal roof tiles are also easy to clean and maintain because they can be hosed down with water. This is unlike asphalt, which requires a more thorough cleaning as roofers have to pressure-wash or scrub the roof meticulously before applying a new roof shingle over the damaged one.

Versatility in design

Another benefit of choosing metal roofing is its versatility in design. Metal offers an array of different finishes and colors that can create an artistic on-roof design. Metal roofing can also be customized to suit any roofline, thereby creating a more personalized roof that reflects your style and personality.


One of the biggest differences between metal roofing and shingle is that aluminum can last your home 50 years until signs of degradation start showing, while different metals have even been known to last 100+ years without ever succumbing to wear and tear! The installation process for these types of roofs is much easier as well, especially because there’s no need for nails. Instead, specially designed clamps hold everything together tightly, which makes repairs easy when necessary.

Fire resistant

Metal roofing is highly resistant to fire due to its ability to withstand high temperatures without sustaining any damage. Thus, making metal roofing a great option in areas prone to wildfires because it’s less likely than shingle or tile roofs to catch fire if hot ashes or embers fall on them.

Commercial RoofingEnvironmentally Friendly

Metal roofing offers an environmentally friendly solution because it can help you save energy while reducing pollution at the same time. This type of roofing is also recyclable, meaning they generate less waste when they are disposed of by recycling companies. Any debris that is produced during the installation process is also usually recyclable. The roof’s durability means it will not need to be replaced as frequently, therefore reducing the waste production.

Energy efficiency

Metal roofing can help you save on your energy bills in the long run because they are able to keep heat in during cold months and out during hot ones, which means you won’t have to turn up your thermostat when summer comes around or use any air-conditioners if this roof type is installed on your home during winter. It’s an eco-friendly way that helps save money by reducing energy costs over time.

Increased Property Value

A roof can make or break a house’s curb appeal, and metal roof roofing comes with a long list of benefits that include its durability, versatility, and looks. Although you may spend more initially on metal roofing, when it comes to selling your property, you will definitely make up for that initial cost.

Drawbacks of Choosing Metal Roofs

Expensive to install

Metal roofing is relatively expensive than other roofing solutions like a shingle, tile, or fiber cement roofing. Installation can cost up to three times more than installing an asphalt roof, and that’s without taking into consideration the cost of all the additional materials needed to install metal roof tiles.

Not everyone can install it.

Metal roofing is not easy and doesn’t require simple tools to install them. This roof type requires specialized equipment, a skilled roofer, and more time. If you don’t do it right the first time around, it can lead to leaks or water damage that could cost hundreds of dollars in repairs in the future.

Labor-intensive installation

The roof itself requires an investment of time and labor to install properly. Depending on the roofing system used, roofers will have to spend more time installing metal roofs than shingle or tile roofs, but the results are worth it in the end.

Vulnerable to dents

Fallen branches, hailstorms, and even walking on it can cause a dent in your metal roof. Not just that, but the paint can also fade and scratch off due to minor damages.

Shingled RoofShingled Roof

For a long time, the traditional choice for roofing shingles has been asphalt. There are many reasons why people prefer this type of material- it’s easy to install and more affordable than other types of roofs. Let’s discuss other benefits of having a shingled roof as well as its drawbacks.

Benefits of Choosing Shingled Roofs


Shingled roofing is a more economical option when compared to metal roofing. In fact, you can install a shingled roof in about half the upfront cost of metal.


The icing on the cake when it comes to this type of roofing is its versatility- shingle roofs come in different designs that can complement any home’s style or architecture. They are also easy to repair, so if one gets damaged, all you have to do is replace only the damaged ones instead of having to entirely re-roof your house like with other roof types.

Easy to install, repair and replace

Shingled roofing is relatively easy to install, repair, and replace. The best part is that you can buy pre-made roof shingles, making it much easier for roofers to complete the work in less time and with fewer roofing tools as well.

It does not require special skills.

Shingles are a common roofing material because they’re easy to install. As such, there are more contractors who can do this job than for roofs made of metal. But you still need to find someone qualified and experienced with the task at hand – it is not as simple as hiring anyone!

Drawbacks of Choosing Shingled Roofs

Short Lifecycle

Traditional roofing materials like shingles have a definite lifecycle, and roofers say that asphalt shingled roofs can last from 12 to 20 years, depending on your location. Its short lifespan means you need to replace it more often than with other roof types.

Heavier roof

Though there have been advances in recent years to reduce the weight of shingles by using less base material, asphalt shingles are still heavier than metal panels. The additional stress on buildings can cause problems over time and make them more susceptible to damage from high winds or other natural disasters that might happen around their area.

Vulnerable to fire

Shingles made today are laminated with asphalt, a combustible material that can make the shingles more susceptible to catching on fire if exposed.

Not environmentally friendly

Many roofing materials are recyclable today to reduce environmental impacts. However, asphalt roof shingles are not included here as they contaminate recycling streams in landfills and even incinerators.

Vulnerable to damages

Shingles are not as durable and reliable, especially during extreme weather conditions such as wind, hail, or snow. If an adhesive isn’t applied correctly to the shingles, they could easily lift off by themselves.

Holds heat inside

The roof also holds the heat inside, which makes your home a lot hotter during summer. This is another reason why shingled roofs are not recommended in areas that have extreme temperatures.

If you are looking for roofing materials that last longer and are guaranteed to give you value for money, then a metal roof is the way to go. Metal roof has a proven track record of lasting more than 50 years, depending on roof designs. It’s also lighter in weight than shingled roofs which means there will be lesser stress on your roof, thus reducing the risk of leaks and damages. As far as style goes, metal roofing certainly does not lack that appeal and can harmonize with any home’s structure regardless of design or texture. However, that does not make it a better option when compared to shingled roofs. Both types of roofing materials have their pros and cons. The right roofing material is the one that suits your needs, preferences, and budget. We hope that you have all the information you need here to decide for yourself what roofing material is best for you.

Learn more about American Central of Tulsa Roofing

American Central Roofing and Construction
7447 E 46th Place
Tulsa, OK 74145

More Roof Repair Locations:

Tulsa | Bartlesville | Owasso | Skiatook | Collinsville | Pawhuska | Dewey | Barnsdall | Sapulpa | Sand Springs | Stillwater | Bristow | Cleveland | Kellyville | Mannford | Hominy | Broken Arrow | Claremore | Catoosa | Wagoner | Coweta | Porter | Inola | Verdigris | Pryor Creek | Jenks | Glenpool | Bixby | Mounds | Beggs | Okmulgee | Muskogee | Henryetta | Haskell

Call Now Button